Dutchess County is actively using 29 Flock Safety Condor Cameras. The pant-tilt-zoom AI enabled cameras are integrated into a network of more than 400 other security cameras, all connected through Flock OS. Photo courtesy Flock Safety

Dutchess County is still using Flock Safety’s surveillance software and video cameras, District Attorney Anthony Parisi confirmed Nov. 16, nearly two months after county law enforcement leaders announced they were withdrawing support for the company’s technology.

“The County currently uses Flock OS and Condor cameras for employee safety and other critical needs,” Parisi wrote in an email to the Herald. “Flock OS also receives video feeds from other sources that support critical safety operations.”

The county deactivated its 65 Flock license plate readers Sept. 25 and requested their removal. The county has since confirmed that most of those license plate readers have been removed. Those cameras photograph passing vehicles and record their plates. Parisi’s statement confirms that shutting them down did not disconnect the county’s broader Flock system.

Flock OS brings video feeds, license plate information, and other public safety data together for investigators. Through the company’s Wing integrations, cameras made by other companies can also connect to the platform. Dutchess County uses more than 400 cameras connected through its Flock OS system, according to the county’s transparency portal.

A $129,100 agreement between the county and Flock effective Oct. 31, 2024, includes Flock OS Advanced, 29 Condor cameras, and Wing integration equipment.

The Condor models listed in that contract have pan, tilt, and zoom capabilities. According to Flock’s website, its pan-tilt-zoom cameras allow operators to watch live video, review recordings, and remotely adjust their view. The company also advertises AI-powered alerts for people and vehicles.

Parisi said his office must put alternatives in place before ending its use of the remaining technology.

“Speaking for the District Attorney’s Office, we have no intention of continuing with Flock Safety and are in the process of winding down our use of its remaining technology,” he wrote. “This transition requires alternative systems to be in place so these essential safety functions can continue without interruption.”

“To be clear, there is nothing budgeted in the District Attorney’s Office 2027 Budget for Flock Safety.”

His commitment to withdraw applied specifically to the district attorney’s office. It did not establish whether other county departments would end their use of Flock.

“As for moving forward, no decisions have yet been made on Flock OS and its future remains uncertain at this time,” Capt. John Watterson of the Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office wrote in a Nov. 5 email to the Herald, when asked whether the software was still in use.

Dutchess County Executive Sue Serino and Sheriff Kirk Imperati did not immediately return the Herald’s requests for comment.

The county’s continued operation of Flock technology drew criticism from Legislator Chris Drago (D-19).

“We were told that Dutchess County was ending its use of all Flock technology — not just ALPRs,” Drago said, referring to automated license plate readers. “We don’t want to be part of the national mass surveillance network created by Flock. We want to get out of it completely and fast. The Legislature will make sure it happens.”

At a Nov. 9 legislative budget hearing, Drago asked Chief Assistant District Attorney Michael Brady where funding for Flock OS appeared in the proposed 2027 budget. Brady called the software “the backbone of that system,” referring to the county’s Analysis and Real-Time Crime Intelligence Center.

“It’s removed. It’s not in there,” Brady said of the funding. But he could not confirm whether the software was still operating, saying he would have to check with Chief Deputy Stephen Reverri.

Even a complete withdrawal would leave another issue: the permissions the county granted Flock to use its data.

The Sheriff’s Office 2023 agreement with Flock gave the company permission to create anonymized aggregated data from footage and material submitted through Wing, “including the training of machine learning algorithms.”

Machine learning is a form of artificial intelligence that learns patterns from examples. The agreement grants perpetual rights to use and distribute aggregated data during and after the contract for purposes including improving Flock’s services, developing other offerings, and crime prevention.

It requires aggregated data to be permanently anonymized so that a person or entity can no longer be identified directly or indirectly. It also preserves agency ownership of the underlying data and says Flock does not sell agency data or aggregated data.

Amendments in 2024 and 2026 left those provisions intact. Ending the agreement would therefore not, by itself, end Flock’s permission to use anonymized aggregated data.

Parisi did not provide a timetable for his office’s withdrawal or identify the systems that would replace Flock.

Join the Conversation

2 Comments

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *