Sen. Michelle Hinchey plans to reintroduce legislation in January that would impose statewide regulations on ALPR cameras including those operated by Flock Safety. Courtesy New York State Senate

State Sen. Michelle Hinchey (D-41) is pushing for statewide restrictions on automated license plate readers, proposing new limits on how government agencies use, retain, and share data collected by systems such as Flock Safety cameras.

The legislation would generally require license plate data to be deleted within 48 hours, restrict the sale and sharing of that information, require agencies to keep records of who accesses it, and establish public reporting requirements for government entities using the technology.

Hinchey first introduced the bill in April. Her office announced a renewed push for the measure this week and said it was drafted in partnership with the New York Civil Liberties Union and a coalition of civil liberties, legal services, and criminal defense organizations.

Automated license plate readers, or ALPRs, use cameras and software to record license plates along with information about when and where a vehicle was photographed. Supporters say they can help police locate stolen vehicles, missing people, and suspects in serious crimes. Privacy advocates have raised concerns about the large databases of vehicle movements the systems can create and who can access that data.

Hinchey’s bill was introduced on April 13 and referred to the Senate Consumer Protection Committee, where it remains. With the 2025-26 legislative session over, Hinchey’s office said the measure is expected to be reintroduced under a new bill number when lawmakers return in January 2027.

Under the legislation, law enforcement agencies could continue using ALPRs for specified purposes, including investigating felonies and locating missing people and stolen vehicles.

The bill would prohibit the sale of ALPR data to private entities, limit access by out-of-state law enforcement without judicial authorization, and require agencies to maintain auditable records showing who searched the data. Agencies would also have to publish annual reports including camera locations and aggregate information about their use. People harmed by violations of the proposed law would be able to sue for damages and attorney’s fees.

“ALPRs, and Flock cameras specifically, have sprung up all around our state without community input and in many cases without the public even knowing,” Hinchey said in a press release. “America is not a surveillance state, and while we want law enforcement to have every tool they can to keep us safe and protect our communities, people’s basic rights must be maintained in the process.”

Hinchey said the legislation was prompted in part by reporting in Pine Plains, where the proposed installation of Flock cameras without public knowledge or Town Board approval drew scrutiny earlier this year.

“We first learned about Flock cameras appearing in communities without public awareness or input through reporting by The New Pine Plains Herald, which brought this issue to our attention,” Hinchey said. “We then worked with the New York Civil Liberties Union on this legislation, recognizing that the unchecked use of ALPRs has grown into a much broader issue that extends well beyond Pine Plains, and across the state and country.”

The Herald first reported on Flock Safety activity in Pine Plains in February and later obtained a two-year, $80,000 agreement for 11 devices that had not been approved by the Town Board. Town officials declared the agreement null and void at an emergency meeting, and in March the board adopted a resolution requiring approval and a governing policy before any town-controlled license plate reader or networked public safety camera system could be activated.

Hinchey’s proposal would establish statewide rules rather than leaving questions over ALPR use and oversight to individual municipalities and county governments.

According to Hinchey’s office, the bill is also backed by The Legal Aid Society, New York County Defender Services, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, the Institute for Justice, the NYU Center on Race, Inequality & the Law, and the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project.

Daniel Schwarz, senior privacy and technology strategist at the New York Civil Liberties Union, said in Hinchey’s release that ALPR systems can create detailed records of routine travel, including trips to workplaces, schools, health care providers, protests and houses of worship.

“Every New Yorker deserves the freedom to live their life without being watched or surveilled,” Schwarz said. He called the legislation an opportunity to establish “comprehensive, common-sense guardrails” around the technology.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *